2/22/2008

NEWS COUNCIL DENIES THREE COMPLAINTS AGAINST THE DULUTH BUDGETEER NEWS

Filed under: — Minnesota News Council @ 4:32 pm
Minneapolis (Feb. 22, 2008) - The Minnesota News Council voted Thursday to deny three complaints against the Duluth Budgeteer News, affirming the paper’s decision to run a Nov. 4, 2007 opinion column critical of Duluth School Board candidate Gary Glass.

Glass, who was elected to the school board in November, complained that an editorial column, "Beware of dirty tricks during the campaign season," unfairly mischaracterized his campaign as "nasty and misleading," and included comments he made prior to becoming a declared candidate for school board. Glass also complained that the timing of the publication was unfair - the paper was published the weekend prior to the election - because he could not offer a rebuttal before Duluth citizens went to the polls.

"Newspapers have a basic right to express political opinion, provided they label it as such," Duluth Budgeteer News editor Jana Peterson told the News Council. "The column did not introduce any new information, something that newspapers try to avoid immediately before an election - that’s part of the reason we don’t allow any political letters to the editor that week."

The News Council voted 10-3 to deny a complaint that it was unfair for the Budgeteer News to publish an opinion column accusing a candidate of dirty tricks without giving him a chance to respond.

On the question of whether it was unfair for the paper to publish a column that included statements that Glass made prior to becoming a declared candidate for school board, the News Council unanimously responded it was not unfair.

The News Council also voted 12-1 to deny a complaint that it was unfair for the Budgeteer News to publish a column that characterized Glass’ campaign as "nasty and misleading."

"All newspapers, weekly or daily, editorialize right before elections," said media member Reed Anfinson, owner and publisher of the Swift County Monitor-News, a weekly paper in Benson. "Our columns provide a summary of what’s happened during the campaign season - we have the opportunity to say ‘here’s why we support this candidate.’"

Media member Karen Boros was concerned about the timing of the publication. "There was no chance for the attacked person to respond," noted Boros.

"It felt unfair when it happened to me," said public member Tom Forsythe recalling an experience similar to Glass’, "but, I do think it’s appropriate for a paper to editorialize prior to an election."

Glass said the News Council’s discussion of the issues was interesting. "I just wish there would have been time to respond to the column," he noted.